WigstonWanderer Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 5 hours ago, Buzzcrow said: Hi Ben, Hi Sam Puel was a defence minded manager and set his team up not to lose and prefered a 4-4-2 diamond formation. It was like watching England under Hodgson with a lot of slow build up and sideways/backwards passing and ended up a very boring 0-0 or the opposition would suss us out and nick a win at St Mary's. Very frustrating and Puel being stubborn would not change his style. Maybe we just didn't have the players for that style of football. Pellegrino is still learning and makes a point of telling us this all the time about how we need to improve. I think our board are looking for another Pochettino but isn't everyone. At the moment the PL looks a bit of a challenge for Pellegrino and we are hoping he comes good in the end. The thing is there isn't a lot of quality managers about for the likes of us and I reckon Puel has learned a lot in his first PL season with Saints. He is very good with young talent and in all honesty I think Puel will surprise a few people including myself. Oh dear, those first 3 sentences seem to encapsulate just about everything that's hated here. Don't like the sound of that at all
roblcfc84 Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 Anyone seen Claudio's Nantes side this year? Very similar to the second half of our the title year (or large parts of it). Low scoring but tight defence. From thr the owners perspective PL and European experience - regardless of style decent track record in both. No compensation to pay and if he agrees to a short term deal surely it's worth s punt. The options are limited.
SpacedX Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 6 hours ago, Buzzcrow said: Puel was a defence minded manager and set his team up not to lose Claude Puelis then.
Unclenobhead Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 6 hours ago, Buzzcrow said: Hi Ben, Hi Sam Puel was a defence minded manager and set his team up not to lose and prefered a 4-4-2 diamond formation. It was like watching England under Hodgson with a lot of slow build up and sideways/backwards passing and ended up a very boring 0-0 or the opposition would suss us out and nick a win at St Mary's. Very frustrating and Puel being stubborn would not change his style. Fvck me!!!!!!! ???
foxfanazer Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 It’s not in our nature to play safe. I just don’t think it’s a right fit at all. Really hope he proves me wrong
Wasyls Pec Deck Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 I have said I'm underwhelmed before, but what we need is for someone to give us an alternative to our plan A, and judge players based on their current abilities (as someone has said above). Can he deliver that? Possibly. It's the most exciting appointment, possibly underwhelming, but it could be the right fit. He should keep Appleton on though, he's clearly got something with the players. I'd be much more alarmed if we are wanted to give it to Giggs, Coleman or Almeyda etc
m4DD0gg Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 Underwhelming, a smaller and crapper club than us sacked this guy not so long ago............as always Rudkin out.
RODNEY FERNIO Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 Smacks of an appointment where a mid table finish is the height of the ambition. Seems a dour character as well .... not sure this will go down well with the current squad. Still got to give the bloke a chance even though the silverware he has won as a manager is minimal.
Unclenobhead Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 11 minutes ago, roblcfc84 said: Anyone seen Claudio's Nantes side this year? Very similar to the second half of our the title year (or large parts of it). Low scoring but tight defence. From thr the owners perspective PL and European experience - regardless of style decent track record in both. No compensation to pay and if he agrees to a short term deal surely it's worth s punt. The options are limited. Compared to the money we have wasted on slimani, musa and mendy the options should be endless!
foxfanazer Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 14 minutes ago, roblcfc84 said: Anyone seen Claudio's Nantes side this year? Very similar to the second half of our the title year (or large parts of it). Low scoring but tight defence. From thr the owners perspective PL and European experience - regardless of style decent track record in both. No compensation to pay and if he agrees to a short term deal surely it's worth s punt. The options are limited. Really shouldn’t be a factor in this decision
LCFC hub Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 Looking for tactical analysis on Puel I came across this. Interesting read on Southamptons pre season last year. http://freshsaints.com/a-tactical-analysis-of-claude-puels-southampton/ Based on the read I'd play something along the lines of this Schmeichel Albrighton Maguire Dragovic Chilwell Ndidi Silva(James/King for now) Iborra Mahrez Vardy Iheanacho
Chester Dontlie Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 I'll reserve my judgement until I see few games at least. I'm glad the owners weren't dilly-dallying with this. Hey Everton have an interim it's a good chance to bang them
foxfanazer Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 1 minute ago, Chester Dontlie said: I'll reserve my judgement until I see few games at least. I'm glad the owners weren't dilly-dallying with this. Hey Everton have an interim it's a good chance to bang them We know interims always win
Chester Dontlie Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 6 minutes ago, foxfanazer said: We know interims always win come on I'm trying to be positive here! EDIT: It has to be said, we had no chance to appoint the likes of Tuchel or Pellegrini or Ancelotti (who I think is past it)... so Puel's probably the best owners could get
Mendi Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 2 hours ago, Stan said: You do realise he has had other managerial jobs. Ranieri was just bumped off by Greece after losing to the Faroe Islands before we took him on. Stop posting crap. Who cares.
fox_favourite Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 4 minutes ago, Chester Dontlie said: come on I'm trying to be positive here! Positive on Foxestalk?! Don't be such a silly sausage!
Ric Flair Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 People say we aren't a defensive team and you're right except our last attacking manager was Sven so it just shows our owners aren't that bothered what the style of football we play we are just expected to be successful. Right now we have a squad geared up for attacking football in forwards and wingers but not in midfield. Our defence isn't as solid as you'd expect for a supposed pragmatic team so it'll be interesting to see how this will work, this is the worry it won't. Our owners, head of recruitment or DOF have no real outlook on the identity of this club it's quite scary.
willie-bell-in-rothley Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 24 minutes ago, RODNEY FERNIO said: Smacks of an appointment where a mid table finish is the height of the ambition. Seems a dour character as well .... not sure this will go down well with the current squad. Still got to give the bloke a chance even though the silverware he has won as a manager is minimal. i read exactly the same when Ranieri was appointed !
Fosse93 Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 Okazaki at the top of a midfield diamond, with 2 strikers ahead of him could be potentially great. (I realise Mahrez will most likely start there)
RODNEY FERNIO Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 1 minute ago, willie-bell-in-rothley said: i read exactly the same when Ranieri was appointed ! Well Claudio wasn't dour ..... anything but !!
Chester Dontlie Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 5 minutes ago, willie-bell-in-rothley said: i read exactly the same when Ranieri was appointed ! Haha, let's hope Claude can do the Claudio! (the early Claudio, I mean )
ozleicester Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 Given some of the sh1t weve been served up for the past 8 months.. i doubt CP will be any more depressing
Fox Ulike Posted 25 October 2017 Posted 25 October 2017 24 minutes ago, Ric Flair said: People say we aren't a defensive team and you're right except our last attacking manager was Sven so it just shows our owners aren't that bothered what the style of football we play we are just expected to be successful. Right now we have a squad geared up for attacking football in forwards and wingers but not in midfield. Our defence isn't as solid as you'd expect for a supposed pragmatic team so it'll be interesting to see how this will work, this is the worry it won't. Our owners, head of recruitment or DOF have no real outlook on the identity of this club it's quite scary. Agreed. It is risking disaster to change our system mid-season. Look what happened to Palace when De Boer came in and tried to change the way they played. It will be Paulo Sousa all over again unless this Puel fella can be flexible.
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.