wokinghamfox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 4 hours ago, Bayfox said: It hits his right hand as he puts it across his back. Hopefully the below link works. Watching it over, without doubt, robbed of potentially two points
UniFox21 Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 2 minutes ago, wokinghamfox said: Watching it over, without doubt, robbed of potentially two points Irrelevant of that, we had 2 golden chances to win.
purpleronnie Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 I've never read the rules about VAR. Can those who are in control of VAR contact the ref if they think it could be a pen or does the ref have to ask for VAR to review it.
wokinghamfox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 1 minute ago, UniFox21 said: Irrelevant of that, we had 2 golden chances to win. Bit of a difference though. In this situation we were denied a scoring opportunity by officials.
UniFox21 Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 28 minutes ago, purpleronnie said: I've never read the rules about VAR. Can those who are in control of VAR contact the ref if they think it could be a pen or does the ref have to ask for VAR to review it. VAR looks at everything and if it thinks it needs a review they hit a button, informs the ref and then look at it.
Guest seanfox778 Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 27 minutes ago, purpleronnie said: I've never read the rules about VAR. Can those who are in control of VAR contact the ref if they think it could be a pen or does the ref have to ask for VAR to review it. I think the ref just carries on as normal and VAR supposedly have a look at each major incident, goals, fouls etc and then advise the ref if they think he got it wrong. I’m not 100% though.
purpleronnie Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 2 minutes ago, UniFox21 said: VAR looks at everything and if it thinks it needs a review they hit a button, informs the ref and then look at it. Seems odd they didn't inform the ref about the penalty then. I can understand why the ref didn't give the pen in real time, and I still think its a decision that could go either way, I think he flicked his fingers out intentionally, but VAR not informing the ref to have another looks seems odd.
st albans fox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 3 minutes ago, purpleronnie said: Seems odd they didn't inform the ref about the penalty then. I can understand why the ref didn't give the pen in real time, and I still think its a decision that could go either way, I think he flicked his fingers out intentionally, but VAR not informing the ref to have another looks seems odd. The fact that there are differences of opinion on here means it wasn’t a clear and obvious error not to award it and it’s no surprise they didn’t deem it worthy of any intervention whilst they examined it further. Had mason given it then they would have to look at the decision in more detail and they wouldn’t have reversed it cos it wasn’t a clear and obvious error to give it. Hence, the on field ref decision remains the most important part of the game but as we saw at villa park, they still screw up
UniFox21 Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 20 minutes ago, purpleronnie said: Seems odd they didn't inform the ref about the penalty then. I can understand why the ref didn't give the pen in real time, and I still think its a decision that could go either way, I think he flicked his fingers out intentionally, but VAR not informing the ref to have another looks seems odd. I was confused as to why it wasn't reviewed, given they review so much. Maybe would've been harsh to give but worthy of a review.
Bayfox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 1 hour ago, wokinghamfox said: Watching it over, without doubt, robbed of potentially two points We would have missed the penalty as it is our luck at the moment. Evans and madders should have won the game.
Guest Danny Clender Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 35 minutes ago, Bayfox said: Evans and madders should have won the game. and that DHL chance for Barnes?
st albans fox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 39 minutes ago, Bayfox said: We would have missed the penalty as it is our luck at the moment. Evans and madders should have won the game. Madders? vards, yes but madders ? What easy chance did he have ?
Post Horn Galloper Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 4 minutes ago, st albans fox said: Madders? vards, yes but madders ? What easy chance did he have ? Vards didn't take his chance but he shot hard and low......sometimesthey go in, sometimes they don't. But l don't think l have seen a ball4 as perfect as that which set up Harvey's chance. The timing, weight and direction of pass were exquisite. He's a complete forward.
st albans fox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 1 hour ago, seanfox778 said: I think the ref just carries on as normal and VAR supposedly have a look at each major incident, goals, fouls etc and then advise the ref if they think he got it wrong. I’m not 100% though. Goals penalties//non penalties red cards ( or what should be a red card) mistaken identity nothing else ..... doesn’t get involved in anything else, irrelevant of being a bad call by the ref, unless it is related to the afore mentioned situations where var becomes relevant So you see that unless the ref makes a decision to award a pen, the bar for var to intervene is high ..... the men in Stockley park clearly felt it wasn’t a cast iron handball so didn’t request mason to hold play whilst they looked more closely. They would have looked at a couple of replays as the game paused naturally due to the injury
Hollyfox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 Good performance from the lads, only poor finishing prevented us from claiming all 3 points. Not having a lot of luck with these handball decisions are we? 😕 My mate, of many years (lifelong Chelsea fan) had a right argument in the away with a few of their supporters. When Chilwell put us 2-1 up, a few dickheads started doing helicopter impressions and singing some offensive song. He went up to them, on his own, and called them F&£7ing disgrace and pointed out about the Mathew Harding tragedy, when Chelsea FC suffered probably their own darkness moment. Nearly came to blows, but fair play to him👍💙
oxford blue Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 Barnes' goal is worth a mention for the very long build up to it - I think the ball went back to Schmeichel twice before the cutting edge passes were found. It worked well today, but it was similar build ups we were caught out v L'pool &Man city. laying against high pressing teams, I'd like to see a longer ball played more often.
MrsJohnMurphy Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 1 hour ago, Hollyfox said: Good performance from the lads, only poor finishing prevented us from claiming all 3 points. Not having a lot of luck with these handball decisions are we? 😕 My mate, of many years (lifelong Chelsea fan) had a right argument in the away with a few of their supporters. When Chilwell put us 2-1 up, a few dickheads started doing helicopter impressions and singing some offensive song. He went up to them, on his own, and called them F&£7ing disgrace and pointed out about the Mathew Harding tragedy, when Chelsea FC suffered probably their own darkness moment. Nearly came to blows, but fair play to him👍💙 Thank him for us
st albans fox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 2 hours ago, Hollyfox said: Good performance from the lads, only poor finishing prevented us from claiming all 3 points. Not having a lot of luck with these handball decisions are we? 😕 My mate, of many years (lifelong Chelsea fan) had a right argument in the away with a few of their supporters. When Chilwell put us 2-1 up, a few dickheads started doing helicopter impressions and singing some offensive song. He went up to them, on his own, and called them F&£7ing disgrace and pointed out about the Mathew Harding tragedy, when Chelsea FC suffered probably their own darkness moment. Nearly came to blows, but fair play to him👍💙 Chelsea have more than their fair share of nobheads
Leicesterpool Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 Got to say Chelsea look a shadow of what they used to be. Should have beaten them was enough chances there, of course we can't forget the incident at the end but we all know VAR never works for us. Perez looked a different player yesterday, he was fantastic and want more of them same like that from him.
Clever Fox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 Evans chance wasn't as easy as it looks. He was body checked by the defender trying to get past him. Which meant he wasn't properly set when the Ball came at him. Which in turn meant he couldn't get it on target. Small margins but the defender just done enough to put him off, Otherwise it was an easy header.
Hollyfox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 54 minutes ago, MrsJohnMurphy said: Thank him for us He's a totally top bloke Very complimentary about LCFC and loves what we've achieved in the last few years. Always a good day with him in West London but always end messy 🍺🍺🍺😄😄
Hollyfox Posted 2 February 2020 Posted 2 February 2020 27 minutes ago, st albans fox said: Chelsea have more than their fair share of nobheads As have we😕
dynamark Posted 3 February 2020 Posted 3 February 2020 I'm just driving up the M1 and had a moment -did Chillwell actually score with his right foot ? If so that must be a first . Interesting yesterday a long VAR rewiew whilst play carried on Man City v TH.What would have happened if either side had scored during the VAR review that would have been interesting
STEVIE B Posted 3 February 2020 Posted 3 February 2020 2 hours ago, dynamark said: I'm just driving up the M1 and had a moment -did Chillwell actually score with his right foot ? If so that must be a first . Interesting yesterday a long VAR rewiew whilst play carried on Man City v TH.What would have happened if either side had scored during the VAR review that would have been interesting The same thing crossed my mind regarding the VAR issue. Also what happens if a horrendous tackle deserves a red card ? I assume a card would be shown ? So l guess a goal would be given. It's a strange one
st albans fox Posted 3 February 2020 Posted 3 February 2020 1 hour ago, STEVIE B said: The same thing crossed my mind regarding the VAR issue. Also what happens if a horrendous tackle deserves a red card ? I assume a card would be shown ? So l guess a goal would be given. It's a strange one No goal would stand but I believe a red card offence would still stand - not 100% sure......this is the reason why a referee blows for a second yellow, even if there is an advantage. To avoid an incident occurring where, for example, the player being dismissed, scores or prevents a goal. This is where the officials screwed up yesterday ....IFAB protocol says that the game should be stopped as soon as the ball enters a neutral area of the pitch, if the VAR thinks an incident needs reviewing ....
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.