MHC Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 Our advantage over Wigan financially is that we have greater earning power as a Prem Club so the fact is £7-8m means a lot less to us than it does to them, which means that they will drive that price up in any way they can including getting into a bidding war with Burnley in the papers. Getting into a bidding war with Burnley is not something I'm worried about. Picture a Ferrari having a race with a Morris Minor.
jayfox26 Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 Could see us getting both Cambiasso and McArthur. I find it odd that Whelan has leaked our bid. Bet Nige us fuming. He'll be lining up a head but at Whelan! He clearly wants to sell McArthur and wants to spark a bidding war. I agree we desperately need signings but I also agree with Nige that we shouldn't be held to ransom. I'd go back with a final bid of £6.5m as I don't reckon he's worth more than that.
Woollett's Wellies Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 It would be interesting to know how Wigan stand with FFP. I suspect they need to lose someone who is on a good wage and worth a decent transfer fee to avoid issues. It's alright for Whelan to try to bump up McArthur's price but he knows that, if there are FFP issues then he needs to get the money in before the transfer window closes and the clock's ticking!
Bamba's Babes Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 Deadline day deal is this one. Once Cambiasso puts his bald head in gear and decides if he is coming or going, this deal will know its future.
Deucalion Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 I don't disagree with anything you have just said, but who here is in full knowledge of all the possible tangents. How can anyone on here possibly come up with a figure. None of us know who else is available to buy, what our budget is, how many players we are looking to buy, what the player's wage demands are, agents fees, signing on fees, lengths of contract, other buyers interested in the same player........the list is endless. Yet we have people suggesting he is worth "no more than £7 million". How could they possibly know what this player or any other player is worth or what value he has? I think we should offer £5,479,513.........based on everything I know about running a football club & negotiating a transfer, i.e. nothing!! Then maybe I've misunderstood your original point. The fact is, we know virtually nothing about the background work or context of a transfer, all we do know is the media reported price, which is often inflated to make a story anyway. Therefore I don't get too excited about the price tags. I trust the current management at the club to be getting value.
Captain... Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 Getting into a bidding war with Burnley is not something I'm worried about. Picture a Ferrari having a race with a Morris Minor. We can outbid Burnley, but I would prefer not to have to try. Whelan has clearly made this public to let every other club know that they are willing to sell him, so get your bids in. I do find the whole process odd. You wouldn't do it in any other walk of life. "How much is that apple...?" "Not telling you, you're going to make an offer?" "Oh, ok, erm 20p?" "Oooh, a good offer but no." "So, erm, 25p?" "Another good offer, but no, just so you know the shop shuts at 5pm, so why don't you go away and come back with a better offer." "But what if someone else wants to buy it?" "I can't make any guarantees, if someone meets my valuation I'll sell." "What's your valuation?" "Not telling." "30p and I'll give you my orange?" "A good offer and I want to sell it to you, I do, come back at 5." 5 o'clock, interior a gravelly throated ginge storms out as you enter muttering something about market leaders. "So how about that apple?" "Well I've had an offer of £3.79 from Droopy the Dog, he said he heard how you were after the apple and really wanted it." "How did he hear that?" "I might have let it slip while he was buying some past their sell by date pears." "Well all the other shops are shut now, £3.80?" "Sold! Here you go... hang on... sorry mate doesn't want to go with you... doesn't think you are going to put him in the middle of the fruit bowl and isn't happy with the location of the fruit bowl, and looking at the rest of your shopping he thinks you lack ambition."
MHC Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 We can outbid Burnley, but I would prefer not to have to try. Whelan has clearly made this public to let every other club know that they are willing to sell him, so get your bids in. I do find the whole process odd. You wouldn't do it in any other walk of life. "How much is that apple...?" "Not telling you, you're going to make an offer?" "Oh, ok, erm 20p?" "Oooh, a good offer but no." "So, erm, 25p?" "Another good offer, but no, just so you know the shop shuts at 5pm, so why don't you go away and come back with a better offer." "But what if someone else wants to buy it?" "I can't make any guarantees, if someone meets my valuation I'll sell." "What's your valuation?" "Not telling." "30p and I'll give you my orange?" "A good offer and I want to sell it to you, I do, come back at 5." 5 o'clock, interior a gravelly throated ginge storms out as you enter muttering something about market leaders. "So how about that apple?" "Well I've had an offer of £3.79 from Droopy the Dog, he said he heard how you were after the apple and really wanted it." "How did he hear that?" "I might have let it slip while he was buying some past their sell by date pears." "Well all the other shops are shut now, £3.80?" "Sold! Here you go... hang on... sorry mate doesn't want to go with you... doesn't think you are going to put him in the middle of the fruit bowl and isn't happy with the location of the fruit bowl, and looking at the rest of your shopping he thinks you lack ambition." quite possibly the best metaphor I have ever seen
Rusko187 Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 We can outbid Burnley, but I would prefer not to have to try. Whelan has clearly made this public to let every other club know that they are willing to sell him, so get your bids in. I do find the whole process odd. You wouldn't do it in any other walk of life. "How much is that apple...?" "Not telling you, you're going to make an offer?" "Oh, ok, erm 20p?" "Oooh, a good offer but no." "So, erm, 25p?" "Another good offer, but no, just so you know the shop shuts at 5pm, so why don't you go away and come back with a better offer." "But what if someone else wants to buy it?" "I can't make any guarantees, if someone meets my valuation I'll sell." "What's your valuation?" "Not telling." "30p and I'll give you my orange?" "A good offer and I want to sell it to you, I do, come back at 5." 5 o'clock, interior a gravelly throated ginge storms out as you enter muttering something about market leaders. "So how about that apple?" "Well I've had an offer of £3.79 from Droopy the Dog, he said he heard how you were after the apple and really wanted it." "How did he hear that?" "I might have let it slip while he was buying some past their sell by date pears." "Well all the other shops are shut now, £3.80?" "Sold! Here you go... hang on... sorry mate doesn't want to go with you... doesn't think you are going to put him in the middle of the fruit bowl and isn't happy with the location of the fruit bowl, and looking at the rest of your shopping he thinks you lack ambition." Is that how Grocery Shopping works
Woollett's Wellies Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 Wigan now reported to be talking to Andy Delort! Last thing I saw was that Charlton couldn't agree a fee with Tours, who were looking for around €5m. I think Whelan's acceptable fee is....Forshaw fee + Delort fee + a drink for 'big Dave', and McArthur will be on the Pie Eater Express down to the KP.
sdb Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 £5 mill seems reasonable to me. We're gonna get shafted I fear, and it might not be the only time over the next week.
Maybes Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 Is he really that good? Dyche will be fuming should we beat them to the signing. 'Many, many pound notes'
Ric Flair Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 It's quite obvious Whelan is keen to do business. I hope we're pushing Cambiasso for an answer with this as back-up. I want this all wrapped up before the weekend.
JJS84 Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 £5 mill seems reasonable to me. We're gonna get shafted I fear, and it might not be the only time over the next week. I don't understand the issue everyone is having with the cost of players. If we pay £10 mil for this lad, so what? if the owners, the manager and Terry and happy with the fee then that's all that matter. its their money, and if we pay it its because we can afford it.
CosbehFox Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 Captain has ripped that analogy off Project Babb and their Ed Woodward sketch. Tut, tut.....
Captain... Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 Captain has ripped that analogy off Project Babb and their Ed Woodward sketch. Tut, tut..... I don't even know what half those words mean. I have never seen that sketch, trust me if I had it would have been much quicker to post it on here than write all that out.
Captain... Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 You mean this? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_cZqTKzS2aI Nothing like that.
CosbehFox Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 http://babb.telegraph.co.uk/2014/08/this-is-how-ed-woodward-would-do-business-in-a-convenience-store/ 5 live played it last night Similarly. Not that I'm bothered at all.
FrankieWorthoYaggedMyWife Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 It's quite obvious Whelan is keen to do business. I hope we're pushing Cambiasso for an answer with this as back-up. I want this all wrapped up before the weekend. I fancy getting 'em both Ricardo! Need this transfer window done, its effecting my work and drinking in the evening
dayday Posted 26 August 2014 Posted 26 August 2014 Sky sources Leicester in talks with Wigan over signing of James McArthur after initial £5million bid rejected...looks like we are trying to negotiate a price...looks promising
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.