Is Maguire the best signing of the summer so far?

[simoncccccc]

http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/40993060

[Jimmy]

for us without a doubt he is

[tom27111]

I'd have preferred Lukaku or Neymar 

 

 

[filbertway]

Pretty decent yeah. So glad we've upgraded with a top quality young player. Hope he gets a run out against his old team on Tuesday 

[st albans fox]

Conceded four on his debut and kept a clean sheet against what was, in effect, a championship club. Ask me again end of September 

[Swarles Barkley]

Its been 2 fvcking games  , one of which was probably against one of the weakest attacks we have ever seen in the prem

[Sublime_Coatsworth]

Sorry, but this us a really dumb question - given we're just two games in and only one of our new signings has actually played (given Kelechi was on mere minutes)

[Tuna]

Far too early for this.

 

 

[Foxxed]

Out of our summer signings one's a goalkeeper who doesn't make the bench, one's an injured additional defensive midfielder, one's an injured striker and then Harry. Even if he rocked up soaked in gin calling anyone under 6"1 a girl he'd still clearly be our best signing.

[simoncccccc]

24 minutes ago, Sublime_Coatsworth said:

Sorry, but this us a really dumb question - given we're just two games in and only one of our new signings has actually played (given Kelechi was on mere minutes)

How rude! If we signed Messi today, and I posted a similar poll, would you say it was a dumb question as you haven't seen him play for us yet? Maybe you're too dumb to vote Undecided.

[Dan]

Undecided. Typical of the media nowadays to churn this out two games into the season. I do think it'll prove to be one of the best though.

[Foxxed]

12 minutes ago, simoncccccc said:

How rude! If we signed Messi today, and I posted a similar poll, would you say it was a dumb question as you haven't seen him play for us yet? Maybe you're too dumb to vote Undecided.

I think Messi might be an outliner. Isn't he quite good at football. I remember someone saying he was good at football. I'm not sure. Undecided.

[Vlad the Fox]

1 hour ago, Foxxed said:

I think Messi might be an outliner. Isn't he quite good at football. I remember someone saying he was good at football. I'm not sure. Undecided.

Nah, too small 

[eblair]

well when he turns to shit, we know the thread to blame

 

[st albans fox]

Leo?  - Too many lefts footed short arses in one team  - don't want him 

[ZeGuy]

Too soon to make a definitive judgement but he's definitely a great signing. Hit the ground running and looking forward to how he's going to boss the defense.

[m4DD0gg]

He reminds me of a young Steve Walsh. Was so refreshing on Saturday to watch one of our cbs pass the ball out of defence. 

[sylofox]

Let's be honest how can anyone vote other than yes. We have a keeper that will not play an injured CM and an injured CF. Out of that list if you remove McGuire I could be our best signing of the summer so far  

[benpicko]

Lmao how is that even an article? It's basically tweet-length 

[desertfox2]

BBC already asking the same thing.

 

http://www.bbc.com/sport/football/40993060

[foxy boxing]

Let's give him a season of playing in the team first but he has shown in his first few games with us what a signing he is and what he is capable of.

[Fox92]

Two games in and they're asking this. Okay.

[Countryfox]

No, I think Jakupovic is a much better signing so far ....          

 

Well you asked a stupid question.    

[Guest Col city fan]

He's looking good and value for money.

For me though, the best summer signing has to be Matic to Man Utd. He was just the player they needed to enable Pogba and others to break forward.

[Bossman Blessed It]

When you consider that Mustafi cost Arsenal virtually double what we paid for Maguire, it's fantastic business. If he plays regularly like he did against Brighton you'd have to look a long way to find another defender who deserves an England start more than him.