Jakemoore Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Obviously this is all just hypothetical fun now that our season is over. But I'm just interested to see what the majority think.. If I could guarantee you a very dramatic play off final win, like a last minute goal or an incredible come back would you take that or stick with our championship winning season?
Vardinhio Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Either or for different reasons really. I'd probably take winning the league over playoffs but playoffs over 2nd.
Danizen Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Win the league. Easily. We've had out fill of Playoffs and my nerves were shredded, last year. It'll be nice to watch them as a neutral.
Tielemans63 Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 I'd stick with being undeniably the best team in the league.
deejdeej Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Tough one, if you could win the play offs as we did under O'Neill then the buzz is immense, but that will very rarely happen.
HEGGSY Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Play offs for me. I just wanna see Leicester at Wembley. Apart from that, league all day long.
ScouseFox Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 the league. in the play offs you get one moment (maybe two if you get a dramatic semi final) of unbridled joy. think of how many days/scenes etc we've had over the course of winning the league this year. too many to even list.
Corky Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Finishing first is better than finishing 3rd-6th. Winning the league will always be the best way to go up.
chicagofox Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 This shouldn't even be a question for anyone. Being the best team in the division and winning the league trumps a play off victory every time. Not to mention the fact that the club can start planning for next season so much earlier.
st albans fox Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 seeing our captain lift that famous old trophy - no contest !!!
ScouseFox Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 unless you're a watford fan, in which case winning a play off semi final is better than winning the league.
Harry - LCFC Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 It's difficult to decide. We were coasting to promotion for weeks this season which was really satisfying in itself but it's not like the full blown anarchy that comes from succeeding in a one game, win or lose situation. My best ever Leicester City experience was last season when we took 6th spot. That was when I was happiest for sure. Can't imagine what winning the play off final would've been like that year...
Guest Bilo Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 102 points with a multitude of records broken is just about the best possible way to go up. As much as I'd have loved Tony K to have slotted away that penalty at Watford last year and to have gone on to beat Palace in the final, it wouldn't have been the same to have gone up with a Cardiff side that bested us by 19 points. We're the best team in this division by a street and the Premier League knows we're going to mean business, rather than just being one of the plucky winners of the play-offs a la Derby. I can't say I'd mind Palace or Hull's seasons next year though.
ealingfox Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Champions, then Play-Offs, then 2nd. You could say Claridge '96 trumps winning the league but that's not a level comparison. Does it trump AGUERRROOOOOOOOOOOO? I don't think so.
Steve_Guppy_Left_Foot Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Just no way the market leaders would ever be near the play-offs.
Harry - LCFC Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Champions, then Play-Offs, then 2nd. You could say Claridge '96 trumps winning the league but that's not a level comparison. Does it trump AGUERRROOOOOOOOOOOO? I don't think so. How is it not be a level comparison? It's a scenario that relates to the question. Man City's triumph is the example that has little to do with it IMO.
Fox92 Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 The league in my opinion. Shows you are the best. But I'd rather win a play off final win at Wembley than finish second.
ealingfox Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 How is it not be a level comparison? It's a scenario that relates to the question. Man City's triumph is the example that has little to do with it IMO. Because Claridge '96 is an example of winning the play-offs in the most dramatic fashion possible, so for it to be a level comparison you would have to consider an example of winning the league in the most dramatic fashion possible (ie Aguero). Of course Claridge '96 beats a campaign where we've known realistically we were going to win the league for well over a month beforehand.
BoyJones Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Always the league, the table shows who is the best team. The play offs are exciting if you win, but soul destroying if you lose, particularly via penalties!!
sk3since03 Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 League. I cant handle play off's very well. Make me want to cry haha Would love to see Leicester at Wembley though!
fox123 Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Been lucky enough to see all of our play-off finals at Wembley and I can assure you, defeat there is heart breaking to say the least! Didn't actually want this season to end, and I guess the only way it wouldn't of, was through the play-offs. We've never won the Football League trophy so winning that is special. A day out at Wembley is always amazing, but I'd rather win a league. Also agree that i'd rather take the play-offs over second. The only final I haven't seen us in at Wembley is the Fa Cup and I would dearly love that to happen and win in my life time.
coolhandfox Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 Play off final is more fun, but only if you win! League, winning it on the last day would be great, we won promotion and the league to early for it to be really exciting!
Leicesterpool Posted 7 May 2014 Posted 7 May 2014 The whole point of winning the league indicates your the best team in the division! So for me it's winning the title, but the only downer of winning the league or finishing second is you miss out on the trip to wembley in play offs!
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.