sm1 Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 17 hours ago, Foxes1 said: Just watched him playing for Poland U-21's and he was substituted early in the 2nd half and he looked well off the pace. As he was going off the commentator mentioned that Cologne were interested in him. Only saw the 1st half but he did look awful, but so did the whole Polish team. It's very difficult for any player to make a contribution when the team plays zero football, all Poland did in that 1st half was hoof the ball to nobody. The problem i see is that Barnes is probably now infront of Kapustka and so the best thing for him would be to leave, either loan or permanant.
Guest Col city fan Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 36 minutes ago, Spicer said: I said in the Amartey thread that "Why would you sell a young player who is good enough to play for their country". Same applies here. A loan however would be a good idea. How does that work? What if the young player was Maltese? Or Finnish? Or Scottish? Don't be bogged down by all the 'asides". Just watch the player and decide if you think they'll make the grade. Personally, I can't see Kaputska as a Premiership standard player, as I can't Amartey. Any young player CAN suddenly improve, making you think 'I weren't expecting THAT from HIM'. But you can't just keep them on just in case. It don't work like that. For as many who do somehow break through, there are many many more that don't.
WigstonWanderer Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 12 minutes ago, sm1 said: Only saw the 1st half but he did look awful, but so did the whole Polish team. It's very difficult for any player to make a contribution when the team plays zero football, all Poland did in that 1st half was hoof the ball to nobody. The problem i see is that Barnes is probably now infront of Kapustka and so the best thing for him would be to leave, either loan or permanant. Hmmm, should fit into our first 11 just fine.
Alex_LCFC Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 He should never have come last August. He should of been loaned straight back to his old club for a season for development playing week in week out
shen Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 12 minutes ago, Alex_LCFC said: He should never have come last August. He should of been loaned straight back to his old club for a season for development playing week in week out
Spicer Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 2 hours ago, Col city fan said: How does that work? What if the young player was Maltese? Or Finnish? Or Scottish? Don't be bogged down by all the 'asides". Just watch the player and decide if you think they'll make the grade. Personally, I can't see Kaputska as a Premiership standard player, as I can't Amartey. Any young player CAN suddenly improve, making you think 'I weren't expecting THAT from HIM'. But you can't just keep them on just in case. It don't work like that. For as many who do somehow break through, there are many many more that don't. Fair but, Ghana and Poland are good teams. With Amartey I agree he is not a good midfielder or full back, I'm trying to hold judgement on his ability as a centre back until I've seen more. As for cabbage, he looked good in the Euro's, since then I've only seen him in one match (Millwall) in which he was the best player on the park. They both may turn out to be good enough, or not up to standard. However my real point is that I don't think we can honestly tell yet.
dayday Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 In the game against Millwall he looked alright, I would sooner loan him out than sell.
MPH Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 20 hours ago, Foxes1 said: Just watched him playing for Poland U-21's and he was substituted early in the 2nd half and he looked well off the pace. As he was going off the commentator mentioned that Cologne were interested in him. Fantastic. Another player we have ruined!
chicagofox Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 3 minutes ago, MPH said: Fantastic. Another player we have ruined! Who are some of the others?
HoustonFox Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 30 minutes ago, chicagofox said: Who are some of the others? Harry Kane
lgfualol Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 Leicester does seem like a place to go for foreign players' careers to either die or blossom.
Thracian Posted 17 June 2017 Posted 17 June 2017 Not seen anything to convince me he'll make our Premiership team. A loan to someone who'd pay his wages wouldn't hurt but he seems to lack the desire we need so it wouldn't matter if he left either. How long did he have to prepare for the Poland game referred to? Yet people say he was off the pace. Why that might be I can't imagine (well, perhaps I could) but it strikes me the lad would be better off back home. Yes, he might come good. Just as City might play six times at Wembley next season. But right now he's made so little impression, I had to check on his Christian name.
Stoney7 Posted 19 June 2017 Posted 19 June 2017 I know he came off injured last match but does anyone know what the injury was or how long he'll be out
mozartfox Posted 19 June 2017 Posted 19 June 2017 On 17. Juni 2017 at 20:34, Will1981 said: We should send him to Belgium for a year. Why had he murdered someone?
brucey Posted 19 June 2017 Posted 19 June 2017 1 hour ago, Stoney7 said: I know he came off injured last match but does anyone know what the injury was or how long he'll be out looked up a few polish articles apparently he played the first game carrying a knee injury... and came off with an ankle injury! the polish media thought he was crap and one of the worst players on the field when he was on he hasn't trained since, so probably out for weeks (or worse if he's done a Mendy) this will be a bit of a problem if we're looking to sell him, which we really should be....
lcfcdamo Posted 19 June 2017 Posted 19 June 2017 I think send him to a championship team for 6 months see how he does
ARM1968 Posted 20 June 2017 Posted 20 June 2017 Neither the cabbage nor Amartey have had enough consistent game time for anyone to form an objective opinion. Both are are young and have raw talent. I say keep them both. Loan out if not required this season, but not sell.
NotTheMarketLeader Posted 20 June 2017 Posted 20 June 2017 6 hours ago, ARM1968 said: Neither the cabbage nor Amartey have had enough consistent game time for anyone to form an objective opinion. Both are are young and have raw talent. I say keep them both. Loan out if not required this season, but not sell. Omg. This again? Amartey had had plenty of game time this last season and to be fair he has proven himself...............to be shit. On Kaputska however I agree we have not seen anywhere near enough of him. As someone said earlier in the thread the only time he's played a game - albeit against Millwall - he created a good few chances, of which Musa spurned all of them. It seems a shame - I vote loan him out.
ARM1968 Posted 20 June 2017 Posted 20 June 2017 20 minutes ago, NotTheMarketLeader said: Omg. This again? Amartey had had plenty of game time this last season and to be fair he has proven himself...............to be shit. On Kaputska however I agree we have not seen anywhere near enough of him. As someone said earlier in the thread the only time he's played a game - albeit against Millwall - he created a good few chances, of which Musa spurned all of them. It seems a shame - I vote loan him out. Plenty? Consistent? Both debatable. I don't think either had the consistent time they needed. However I too would be in favour of loans for both.
Blue ROI Posted 20 June 2017 Posted 20 June 2017 Needs to be loaned out. Our midfield area as of now is just too packed for him to stand out.Starting so soon for Poland created a hype around him that cant have helped. If he went to a club in championship or league one it would be of benefit to him. Poland likely to make the world cup next year staying at Leicester is not an option really if he wants to make that squad. He might be looking at a move permanently.
MPH Posted 20 June 2017 Posted 20 June 2017 On 6/17/2017 at 10:29, Alex_LCFC said: He should never have come last August. He should of been loaned straight back to his old club for a season for development playing week in week out On 6/17/2017 at 10:42, shen said:
Guest Col city fan Posted 20 June 2017 Posted 20 June 2017 47 minutes ago, ARM1968 said: Plenty? Consistent? Both debatable. I don't think either had the consistent time they needed. However I too would be in favour of loans for both. Ndidi is 20 yrs old and has had approx half a season in a blue shirt. Does that mean he requires 'more game time' before we make an assessment of the player? Id pretty much decided on Amartey after half a dozen games..and said so on this forum. Id also pretty much decided on Ndidi after even fewer games. And said so on this forum. If they are good enough, the age don't matter. Of the little ive seen of Kaputska, there is a glimpse of some skill there. But he looks generally miles off being a Prem standard player imo.
ARM1968 Posted 20 June 2017 Posted 20 June 2017 Col - you applied for chief scout yet? You're truly wasted in here
gurru991 Posted 20 June 2017 Posted 20 June 2017 On 6/17/2017 at 11:39, chicagofox said: Who are some of the others? Like Barnes and Chilwell, Gray and maybe Elliot Moore. We are death to young players obviously
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.