The Doctor Posted 23 September 2018 Posted 23 September 2018 4 minutes ago, pazzerfox said: Anyone can pass 5 yards. He hasn't got a defence splitting pass in him! Good job that's not the job of either of the double pivot in a 4-2-3-1 then eh?
yorkie1999 Posted 23 September 2018 Posted 23 September 2018 7 minutes ago, pazzerfox said: Anyone can pass 5 yards. He hasn't got a defence splitting pass in him! wes morgan can't
UPinCarolina Posted 23 September 2018 Posted 23 September 2018 He’s certainly making a great number of posters here eat crow. Pleased to see him come good. I’m sure that he’s had a difficult time personally with being injured and struggling to become the type of player he was before the foot and ankle issues set in. Congratulations are in order for completing his comeback, much less doing so in such fine fashion.
Bunyip Posted 23 September 2018 Posted 23 September 2018 He wears Pink boots. No credibility whatsoever.
Foxxed Posted 23 September 2018 Posted 23 September 2018 Mendy is better than Ndidi currently. I wouldn't mind making Ndidi fight for his place amongst the better DM passers on the bench. Ndidi is great but giving the ball away at DM will and does leave us vulnerable to counter attack.
Shane Posted 25 September 2018 Author Posted 25 September 2018 Imo he is our best CM because of his all round ability
fuchsntf Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 On 24/09/2018 at 01:09, Foxxed said: Mendy is better than Ndidi currently. I wouldn't mind making Ndidi fight for his place amongst the better DM passers on the bench. Ndidi is great but giving the ball away at DM will and does leave us vulnerable to counter attack. Yes ,end of last season,and these 6 games,he's made the great intercepts,broke up play,but we have to be honest(or is it me!!!) Ndidi ,getting the rebound and picking out consistent easy,short,or long passes,is becoming a rarity!! unlike some I don't go out looking for weaknesses,or errors,but it's become too noticable,that we are breaking up Play,but not using the advantage,on a few occasions we should.I don't expect great,but a quiet consistency will do. It's been re-feeding the opposition,too many times. If we can carry him on his spoiling play ,I am for him staying in the team,but won't be disappointed If Puel rested him,for Silva or IBorra.
Bigboss204 Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 Do we really need to play Mendy alongside Ndidi? From what I've seen of them they are very similar types of player - surely we are better having someone who can get on the ball a bit more now we are looking to play possession based football. Silva doesn't really merit a starting spot given his performances, I would like to see Ndidi/Mendy and Iborra.
HankMarvin Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 On 24/09/2018 at 00:09, Foxxed said: Mendy is better than Ndidi currently. I wouldn't mind making Ndidi fight for his place amongst the better DM passers on the bench. Ndidi is great but giving the ball away at DM will and does leave us vulnerable to counter attack. 4th best tackler in the league this season take him out the team and replace with who that will make 4-5 tackles constantly a game sure he passing may not be the greatest but it can’t be argued he has been one of the most consistent tacklers in the league for a Cple of years. out of them tackles I wonder how many goals he has stopped, considerably more than he has caused by miss placing passes no doubt
Lesta Legend Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 Mendy is doing Brilliant at the moment and has felt like a brand new signing. Says a lot about him to come back from being injured and written off by our fans to making the place his own. However he is NOT better than Wilf in the defensive midfield role, Wilf's stats are still higher and saying that his form has dropped so he can improve. But I like Mendy so deserves all due credit.
HighPeakFox Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 On 23/09/2018 at 22:49, pazzerfox said: Anyone can pass 5 yards. Not true.
UPinCarolina Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 38 minutes ago, Bigboss204 said: Do we really need to play Mendy alongside Ndidi? From what I've seen of them they are very similar types of player - surely we are better having someone who can get on the ball a bit more now we are looking to play possession based football. Silva doesn't really merit a starting spot given his performances, I would like to see Ndidi/Mendy and Iborra. I think we would be better off dropping Ndidi at this point than Mendy, and bringing in Silva for his link-up play with Maddison. I see your point, however. Ndidi just seems to be the more logical drop as he's been on a poor run of form lately and may be tired.
Foxxed Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 32 minutes ago, HankMarvin said: 4th best tackler in the league this season take him out the team and replace with who that will make 4-5 tackles constantly a game sure he passing may not be the greatest but it can’t be argued he has been one of the most consistent tacklers in the league for a Cple of years. out of them tackles I wonder how many goals he has stopped, considerably more than he has caused by miss placing passes no doubt Probably not going to find a better tackler but if Hamza becomes half as good but retains and passes the ball better I wouldn't mind rotating them. Ndidi's guaranteed a starting place on the basis of this tackling alone - a bit of competition may force him to concentrate on his passing and ball retention.
GingerrrFox Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 2 hours ago, HankMarvin said: 4th best tackler in the league this season take him out the team and replace with who that will make 4-5 tackles constantly a game sure he passing may not be the greatest but it can’t be argued he has been one of the most consistent tacklers in the league for a Cple of years. out of them tackles I wonder how many goals he has stopped, considerably more than he has caused by miss placing passes no doubt Yeah but being a team that now wants to dominate possession against the smaller sides, the counter to your argument is that, would Ndidi need to make as many tackles if we weren’t sloppy in the middle of the park and losing possession? Ndidi’s tackling stats are there for all to see but he needs to cut out the simple mistakes which lead to losing possession, otherwise he will find himself replaced in the long run.
Simoken Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 2 hours ago, Lesta Legend said: However he is NOT better than Wilf in the defensive midfield role, Wilf's stats are still higher and saying that his form has dropped so he can improve. Stats mean nothing when his movement and pitch covering is way ahead of wilf. In time this will benefit him in the long run.
murphy Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 On 23/09/2018 at 23:43, UPinCarolina said: He’s certainly making a great number of posters here eat crow. Pleased to see him come good. I’m sure that he’s had a difficult time personally with being injured and struggling to become the type of player he was before the foot and ankle issues set in. Congratulations are in order for completing his comeback, much less doing so in such fine fashion. What? Is that an American expression? I must admit, I wanted him sold, but as a... erm... crow eater, I am delighted by his good start to the season. He seems to have jumped ahead of Silva and Iborra and made himself our second best midfielder.
Guest Col city fan Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 4 hours ago, UPinCarolina said: I think we would be better off dropping Ndidi at this point than Mendy, and bringing in Silva for his link-up play with Maddison. I see your point, however. Ndidi just seems to be the more logical drop as he's been on a poor run of form lately and may be tired. Gotta be honest. Judging the last few games, if we were gonna drop either Mendy or Wilf, I’d be dropping Wilf. Mendy looks more mobile and cleans up better. I could easily imagine Mendy alongside a deeper playmaker
martyn Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 We would benefit massively if either Ndidi or Mendy could break the lines with their passing and get the ball into Maddison quicker and in more dangerous areas before a defence can set itself. Ndidi is plumbing new depths with his distribution this season and whilst Mendy is neat and tidy, we would be a more dangerous proposition if one of them (probably Mendy) could be a bit more progressive on occasion.
Fosse93 Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 Having Mendy AND Ndidi both play is overkill for me. A new CM that can pick a pass would be top of my list come January.
UPinCarolina Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 17 minutes ago, murphy said: What? Is that an American expression? I must admit, I wanted him sold, but as a... erm... crow eater, I am delighted by his good start to the season. He seems to have jumped ahead of Silva and Iborra and made himself our second best midfielder. I wasn't aware that it was a solely American expression, but it's an idiom defined by Merriam-Webster as meaning "to admit that one was wrong or accept that one has been defeated"
murphy Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 20 minutes ago, UPinCarolina said: I wasn't aware that it was a solely American expression, but it's an idiom defined by Merriam-Webster as meaning "to admit that one was wrong or accept that one has been defeated" Well, there you go. You learn something every day!
RumbleFox Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 24 minutes ago, martyn said: We would benefit massively if either Ndidi or Mendy could break the lines with their passing and get the ball into Maddison quicker and in more dangerous areas before a defence can set itself. Ndidi is plumbing new depths with his distribution this season and whilst Mendy is neat and tidy, we would be a more dangerous proposition if one of them (probably Mendy) could be a bit more progressive on occasion. Whilst Mendy certainly is the better passer I think you have gone slightly OTT here. I wish people would be more rational and less hyperbolic sometimes. Not only because I am a sad loser and it annoys me but also because it ruins your own point. Mendy's pass conversion rate is better than Ndidi but Ndidi's passing (so far this season) is actually better than last so to say this season he is "plumbing new depths" just seems a weird comment based upon pre-held beliefs rather than the facts? The reality would be to say something more along the lines of "Whilst Ndidi is young and is showing signs that his passing is actually better this season than last it is still a weak point in his game. He is still behind Mendy in that area and his game would benefit if he improved". X
st albans fox Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 If we are playing 4-2 then the two need to be disciplined holders and v fit, covering behind the overlapping FB’s The four up top are responsible for creativity - papy and wilf could become as crucial a partnership as NG and DD were
okie fox Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 People making comparisons need to take into account the number of corners Ndidi has headed out of danger this season.
RumbleFox Posted 25 September 2018 Posted 25 September 2018 By the way I realise passing completion does not necessarily = good distribution I just think the language was a wee bit harsh on the 21 year old lad. X
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.