FA Cup 22/23

[Parafox]

They need to ban the stuttering run ups on penalties 

It puts the keeper at such an unfair disadvantage 

Edited 3 June 2023 by Parafox

[st albans fox]

If your arm is above shoulder level then if it’s struck then it’s a pen (unless it’s deflected onto it) 

 

we’ve suffered enough from those over the past few seasons 

[Fox92]

At least that’s made it more interesting. Man City are so good but I find them boring to watch. Awful they scored so early because they were coasting the game.

[foxy boxing]

There needs to be a distinction between deliberate and unintentional.

[TJQuik]

Game on!

[Arkie Bennett]

Similar to at least one penalty given against us (Ndidi?). Crap interpretation of what handball is, but them's the rules (laws).

[lcfcfoz]

This ends 2-2 United win on pens 6-5 100% guaranteed,  I'm from the future, winning pen taker casemiro

[Fox92]

Just now, foxy boxing said:

There needs to be a distinction between deliberate and unintentional.

There does but it’s to fine a line. Players will always moan at anything anyway. 

[foxes_rule1978]

Just now, Fox92 said:

At least that’s made it more interesting. Man City are so good but I find them boring to watch. Awful they scored so early because they were coasting the game.

Yeah I was worried it was going to be a battering, I want a good game still 

[VinceNoir]

2 minutes ago, Fox92 said:

Not me. Man City’s fanbase is worse.

Not encountered many bad Man City fans over here (Denmark), whereas United’s are absolutely horrendous 

[Arkie Bennett]

1 minute ago, Parafox said:

They need to ban the stuttering run ups on penalties 

It puts the keeper at such an unfair disadvantage 

Particularly Fernandes with his tiptoe through the tulips routine.

[FoxyLeon]

Just now, HybridFox said:

Grealish knew what he was doing

 

He's trying to not collide with someone in mid air, that's what he was doing.

[Lcfc82]

Calls like that should stay with the on field decision. The rules need changing.

[st albans fox]

Just now, Parafox said:

They need to ban the stuttering run ups on penalties 

Why?  You can’t stop your run up but there’s an art to stuttering and still keeping control of the kick. The advantage is supposed to be with the  kicker. 

[coolhandfox]

Standard of refs gets worse by the week, not even sure some of them understand the laws of the game.

[FrankieADZ]

was rashford offside in the build up too

its another decision going Utd's way,complete farce is all i can say for VAR after the casamiro challenge too

Edited 3 June 2023 by FrankieADZ

[kingkisnorbo]

I'll say it again, absolutely no respect for any manager who turns up to Wembley on cup final day without a suit on. 

[ithuriel]

Dislike both teams and Guardiola, hate when he goes and hugs opposition players and has an on field chat after the match, that was a pen under current rules and both sides would have pushed for it.

[STEVIE B]

If you're jumping for the ball, how on earth can that be judged as 'arm in an unnatural position'. 

Unfortunately we have too many people officiating, who don't understand the game, or that jumping means you're arms move too. 

[Sampson]

It goes past him like a fraction of a second before. The slow motion replay doing all the leg work in that var decision, no way it gets given if it’s just shown in real time.

[FoyleFox]

5 minutes ago, lcfcfoz said:

Penalty all day. With the current rules

When it suits.

[davieG]

Just now, foxy boxing said:

There needs to be a distinction between deliberate and unintentional.

You mean like it used to be, trouble is people argue that is subjective and open to mistakes. They don’t make mistakes now.

[Stuntman_Mike]

It's harsh and unlucky for Grealish but that's the right decision with the current rules. Definitely a pen for me

[RowlattsFox]

Arm is raised but its ridiculous. 

[Corky]

I get why it is a penalty but to me it is a natural result of twisting around.

 

These decisions where the ref has to confirm via the screen what they've been told needs to change.