Sir Shep Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 5 minutes ago, foxes_rule1978 said: Alli clearly has his arm up, the ball clearly hits that arm... I don’t see how it can be anything other than a penalty. At the World Cup I remember this given often And the Everton player was leaning on top of him, not saying your wrong it’s just what it looked like to me.
kyleolly Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 How’s that a red he hardly touched him it’s how the Everton player has landed that has ****ed his leg
Cadno'r Cymoedd Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Just now, Finnegan said: Nobody ever quite means THAT (except Roy Keane) but its a stupid tackle on a guy who just clattered him in the face. He accelerates when he sees Gomes getting the ball and deliberately trips him. He might not be trying to cause him an injury and he obviously regrets the extent of it but he was deliberately trying to foul him. The Son tackle did not do the damage though. 1
Arkie Bennett Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 I think Son should have been sent off before then anyway, but the red for that foul looked harsh.
Wolfox Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Just now, Mark 'expert' Lawrenson said: It was reckless but not a sending off, Son had a poor 5 minutes there Saw the replay…. Was a foul, but, not sending off Horrendous for Gomes 3
lifted*fox Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 son's tackle ain't even a yellow how can he have known he was gonna go flying into Aurier? butterfly effect
StriderHiryu Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Poor guy, that could be a career ender. Everton have been terrible all season, but no one deserves that and I feel sorry for their fans that their best player has suffered that.
Finnegan Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Just now, Cadno'r Cymoedd said: The Son tackle did not do the damage though. Well I mean, it does, doesn't it? If Son doesn't trip him up it never happens. Incidentally, in a weird way I do agree with @ttfn, it's kinda only really a yellow card tackle. But he does foul him, it is a deliberate trip and he wouldn't have fallen in to the Aurier challenge if Son hadn't done anything. 1
yorkie1999 Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 1 minute ago, Cadno'r Cymoedd said: The Son tackle did not do the damage though. No, it looked like it was the other player flying into him after he’d been brought down by son 2
Guest Chocolate Teapot Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Aurier should have been sent off rather than Son, but Son lost his head and hacked him.
Guest ttfn Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Just now, Cadno'r Cymoedd said: The Son tackle did not do the damage though. This is what I don’t get, Aurier has committed a pretty blatant red card tackle there and Son’s been sent off for it? Given the way Gomes was travelling as well, it’s fortunate Aurier didn’t get injured too. Dreadful injury but that’s not been caused by Son’s tackle. You can’t start sending players off based on whether the player gets injured.
Mark_w Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 I'm no Tottenham fan but I'd be absolutely livid if I was. How can VAR not rescind that red card? The referee shouldn't be changing his mind about the card he's showing based on the injury anyway, but for VAR to not intervene and save Son from suspension is ridiculous.
casablancas Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 You know it’s a poor game when all the talking points are; tackles, red cards, dives and of course VAR. 1
Popular Post TheSomersetFox Posted 3 November 2019 Popular Post Posted 3 November 2019 I'd be devastated if any of our players suffered that. Good luck to the bloke in his recovery 7
foxes_rule1978 Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 It is a yellow card challenge if what happens next doesn’t happen... 1
Jimothy Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Son trips him, that's a yellow, similar to Choudhury on Salah. Aurier comes steaming in and clatters Gomes as he's falling, totally out of control, and he actually causes the injury, and injury or not probably deserved a red.
UniFox21 Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Just now, Facecloth said: Son trips him, that's a yellow, similar to Choudhury on Salah. Aurier comes steaming in and clatters Gomes as he's falling, totally out of control, and he actually causes the injury, and injury or not probably deserved a red. Potential for the suspension to be flipped? Surely this is what VAR should be for?
urban.spaceman Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 I loathe Spurs but I'm so gutted for Son there. 2
Jimothy Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Just now, UniFox21 said: Potential for the suspension to be flipped? Surely this is what VAR should be for? Shouldn't need reviewing after the game, it should have been reviewed during it like you say. 2
urban.spaceman Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Just now, UniFox21 said: Potential for the suspension to be flipped? Surely this is what VAR should be for? Not sure - it can only be used to award a straight red I think.
orangecity23 Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Almost need to share the red between Aurier and Son. Very weird foul, absolutely horrendous consequences.
Finnegan Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 I lost track in all the chaos. Is it 10 v 10 now? Had Everton used all their subs?
doubledeckerderek Posted 3 November 2019 Posted 3 November 2019 Putting the emotion aside, as referees are supposed to, again shows what a rubbish referee Atkinson is. Not sure it was even a yellow. But horrible accident. Similar to the David Busst injury. Also shows what absolutely classless/we’re victims wankers everyone from Liverpool (ok- slight exaggeration) are. All the boo-ing from the Gladys St end. Melts...
Recommended Posts