Bluearmyfox28 Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 Not sure on this one personally. For me we should go & get Jonathan Tah.
Langston Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 He might be a bit shit but he'd be fourth choice, could do worse if we fancy Benkovic to improve elsewhere on loan before we give him a crack here. Bit expensive mind, and it does reek of Congerton. 1
Jonezy Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 Squad players for 15 million. Football has gone proper mad. Even as a Dane, I am not that impressed with Jannik. He is a giant, but very slow and immobile. We do need some more physicality as times, so it kinda makes sense. 3
Haywood_6 Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 Bloody hell don't waste money on Vestergaard, he's a liability. I'd rather take dragovic back on loan!
Sol thewall Bamba Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 Would also suggest that Benko isn't seen as a viable option.
GingerrrFox Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 12 minutes ago, Sol thewall Bamba said: Would also suggest that Benko isn't seen as a viable option. He’s still highly thought of but we are keen for him to go on loan in the Championship to help with his development. He’s learning nothing from playing U23 matches and occasionally sitting on the bench.
casablancas Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 2 hours ago, lcfceaves said: One of the worst and immobile centre backs in the premier league... Lee Congerton effect? We have been praised and rightly so, for our transfer dealings over the last few years. This however is the complete opposite Robert Huth? That’s the sort of response he got when we first loaned him. He turned out ok. 2 1
st albans fox Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 The fans most keen on this deal are derby ones ......
Dan Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 5 hours ago, Ric Flair said: If this is true, this is why we had worries over Congerton and Rodgers on recruitment. The man is garbage. One of the worst defenders in the league in the last few years. Exactly this. Is this seriously the best we can do? Just seems a really daft signing to me. Cannot get my head around it.
NaijaFox Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 12 hours ago, NasPb said: its a no from me Same here
rico Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 Love how everyone's getting their panties in a twist over this
volpeazzurro Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 48 minutes ago, Jonezy said: Squad players for 15 million. Football has gone proper mad. Even as a Dane, I am not that impressed with Jannik. He is a giant, but very slow and immobile. We do need some more physicality as times, so it kinda makes sense. We've just managed to get rid of that big slow lump McGuire, we don't need another one! 🤣
ithuriel Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 If the manager and coaching team thinks he is worth a punt at 15 million then they must think there is a player there they can work with.
VLC86 Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 (edited) 36 minutes ago, casablancas said: Robert Huth? That’s the sort of response he got when we first loaned him. He turned out ok. No it wasn’t. Premier League winner and regular in the league at a time when we really needed experience, completely different. Edited 23 January 2020 by Costock_Fox 1
MPH Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 1 hour ago, RoyFox said: We’re only 4/5 wins away from Top 4, thanks to the inconsistency of teams below us. I’d rather we went for someone in the summer that follows the same successful model of late (21-24 years old, with upside (helped by decent coaching), and potential to threaten the starting XI CB’s long term. Plus potential for profit and reinvestment). experienced center backs are a must for me... we have wes and evans but not sure if Wes will be playing for another year, so why not?
Gerard Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 £15m isn't pocket change as some on here suggest. It isn't much less than our average net spend per season on transfers. I'm just not a fan whatsoever in buying 27yo reserves who have no expectation of forcing their way into the first team.
Langston Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 1 hour ago, Sol thewall Bamba said: Would also suggest that Benko isn't seen as a viable option. Yet. Perhaps the staff think he'll be better for us down the line if he goes and gets regular games and is a little more polished? This transfer just seems like a (relatively) budget stop-gap until Benkovic is ready and Evans starts creaking a little.
WilmslowFox Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 (edited) Weird if we're looking at spending £15M for a 4th choice CB, when this has probably been our strongest position in the U23s over the last few seasons. Johnson, Hughes and Knight have all been impressive (including appearances with the first team in pre-season friendlies while half the squad were away following the World Cup), so it would be nice to see at least one of them given a chance. I think I'm right in saying that after nearly a year in charge, Brendan has yet to give a competitive debut to any of the development squad, even off the bench in the early rounds of a cup competition, as is kinda traditional. Edit: unless you consider Benkovic a member of the development squad, which I don't. Edited 23 January 2020 by WilmslowFox 1
NaijaFox Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 (edited) 2 hours ago, Deeg67 said: I think you're confused, since you seem to think anyone who wouldn't be first team for Barca or Bayern is shit. You mean anyone who couldn’t be first team for Southampton? While I wouldn’t call him shit myself, there are literally hundreds of players on a sliding scale between not being first team for Barca or Bayern and not being first team for the Saints. I would suggest we keep looking or at worst get him on loan with option to buy. Overall, a most underwhelming development. > Edited 23 January 2020 by NaijaFox 1
NaijaFox Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 5 hours ago, Reg Vardy said: Well if he is that crap Southampton are top half in the premiership, decent player, 100% attitude, good price, or 75m Tarkowski, Ake or Dunk......ideal with Champions league just around the corner.....gerrimin Except it seems they got there once they stopped playing him.
Gerard Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 (edited) It just seems a pointless signing when we're going to a club who are a lesser level (temporarily at least) or historically a similar level club to us and giving them good money for one of their reserves who has already levelled on their potential. It would be like us selling Mendy for good money at the start of the season when he's 27 and just a squad player and forever destined to be just that. Edited 23 January 2020 by Gerard
NaijaFox Posted 23 January 2020 Posted 23 January 2020 5 hours ago, weller54 said: No no no no no no no... Yes. Feel the same way... If he ends up here, he’ll get my full support (as long as he’s not shit ). 1
Recommended Posts