egg_fried_rice Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Think it should've been a yellow, but you can see why it was given and it's never getting overturned. Moronic decision to make a challenge like that it that situation, Fulham were right in the game and probably should've been one up.
filbertway Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Chance to look at that and still a red. VAR is a failed experiment
TheSomersetFox Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 It's a strong tackle, slightly high, but not a red. Mount is a nob
Fox42 Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 We shouldn’t moan about that. That rules him out when we travel to Craven Cottage.
RowlattsFox Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 It's a red because Azpilicueta is screaming around on the floor. Fine now I see. He jumps in the air to make it look worse. 2
filbertway Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Just now, egg_fried_rice said: Think it should've been a yellow, but you can see why it was given and it's never getting overturned. Moronic decision to make a challenge like that it that situation, Fulham were right in the game and probably should've been one up. Nope. You're first point is right. Everything else you've said is why the wrong decisions are made.
Arkie Bennett Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 1 minute ago, Vacamion said: Azpilicueta rolled and rolled and screamed after the tackle, and his teammate squared up to Robinson. Didn't help. Definite yellow made red by the overreaction which the ref allowed himself to be influenced by.
Unabomber Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Just now, filbertway said: Chance to look at that and still a red. VAR is a failed experiment They barely even looked at it. The ref didn’t even go to the monitor unless I missed it. Compare that to how long they reviewed the Shaw one which was the same but he got a yellow. Just goes to show the corrupt state of VAR. 1
kingfox Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 2 minutes ago, RowlattsFox said: It's a red because Azpilicueta is screaming around on the floor. Fine now I see. He jumps in the air to make it look worse. He’s bloody lucky to half skip that challenge tbf. If his leg was planted, Robinson would have probably snapped it in half. Out of control and reckless. 4
filbertway Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 1 minute ago, Unabomber said: They barely even looked at it. The ref didn’t even go to the monitor unless I missed it. Compare that to how long they reviewed the Shaw one which was the same but he got a yellow. Just goes to show the corrupt state of VAR. They saw as much as we did. The problem is the commentators and ref both though it should be a red, for the same reasons the chap above said. "I think it's a yellow but I've seen a red given".
The Quick Brown Fox Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 28 minutes ago, FoyleFox said: It's disappointing there's no option to not have the commentators instead of crowd noise. Tyler has been wittering needlessly, does he know his job is match commentary? Mute?
Sharpe's Fox Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 VAR will never work while the ego of the referees and their mates come before whether a decision is correct or not. 1
Miquel The Work Geordie Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Should be sent off for that spelling of Anthony to be honest, talk about PC gone mad 1
jammie82uk Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Surprised at all the comments saying it’s not a red Law 12 states Any player who lunges at an opponent in challenging for the ball from the front, from the side or from behind using one or both legs, with excessive force or endangers the safety of an opponent is guilty of serious foul play.
Corky Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 13 minutes ago, Unabomber said: Also Tyler does this weird thing before games where he goes “AND IT’S LIVE” as if it is some catchphrase that we are all gagging to hear. It used to occur before an advert break. Now he shouts it then they cut to the players just standing around.
StanSP Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Who's gonna be the Sharkey of this thread then? Approaching 20k posts. Currently on 18,552...
AjcW Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 (edited) 2 minutes ago, jammie82uk said: Surprised at all the comments saying it’s not a red Law 12 states Any player who lunges at an opponent in challenging for the ball from the front, from the side or from behind using one or both legs, with excessive force or endangers the safety of an opponent is guilty of serious foul play. Think the issue. As ever. Is inconsistency. Luke Shaw will be on the pitch tomorrow when he should be serving a 3 match ban Edited 16 January 2021 by AjcW 1
BenKimbo Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Only no broken bones because Azpilicueta didn’t plant his leg. Robinson didn’t know if his leg was planted or not so he would have made this type of challenge either way. Red card is the right decision.
Spiritwalker Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 What ever happened to players being yellow carded for waving imaginary cards?
filbertway Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 3 minutes ago, jammie82uk said: Surprised at all the comments saying it’s not a red Law 12 states Any player who lunges at an opponent in challenging for the ball from the front, from the side or from behind using one or both legs, with excessive force or endangers the safety of an opponent is guilty of serious foul play. So you can put in a perfectly timed challenge that wins the ball and gets a red. If tackle that is hard regardless of result is a red then fair play.
Finnegan Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 23 minutes ago, The Bear said: Very much the former. Once we get out of lockdown, get the fans back and can have a normal break and pre-season things will be much better for everyone involved. FWIW, as a neutral looking in, that sounds about right. As long as there's no falling out in the squad and he keeps everyone on side I imagine you're right. You've got the advantage of knowing the relegation places are already more of less wrapped up so it's basically a free season tbh. 1
Steve Earle Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 8 minutes ago, AjcW said: Think the issue. As ever. Is inconsistency. Luke Shaw will be on the pitch tomorrow when he should be serving a 3 match ban The little-known Law 12A says that Law 12 ‘shall not apply to a player registered with Manchester United’. 2 1
Scotch Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Think he has that nasty side to his game. Saw a challenge of his last year that would have made Vinne Jones blush.
Ian Nacho Posted 16 January 2021 Posted 16 January 2021 Why is Martin Tyler talking about Brazilian benders 1
Recommended Posts