ajthefox Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 As unlikely as it is that Liverpool don't win the league, I don't see how anyone can legitimately argue that Option 2 is fair at all - it simply isn't. I'd be for an increased amount of teams if the season can't finish but if you say the season is over, it has to be the same rule for all surely. Liverpool have not mathematically won the title, giving it to them and ignoring every other team's position is just wrong.
st albans fox Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 28 minutes ago, ajthefox said: As unlikely as it is that Liverpool don't win the league, I don't see how anyone can legitimately argue that Option 2 is fair at all - it simply isn't. I'd be for an increased amount of teams if the season can't finish but if you say the season is over, it has to be the same rule for all surely. Liverpool have not mathematically won the title, giving it to them and ignoring every other team's position is just wrong. What does ‘fair’ have to do with anything this is about money ........
Vestan Pance Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 58 minutes ago, Paninistickers said: They HAVE to finish the season as somewhat unbelievably, it is not written into the rules what would happen in the event of a competition having to be cancelled. This means any decision other than completing the season is liable to legal challenge Hard to believe no one thought there may be a situation one day where the season might not be completed. Really quite pathetic from this huge industry.
Adster Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 3 hours ago, FOXSE said: There is a stong argument that as Liverpool are 25 points clear, it's inevitable they would have won the league. But teams are out side the relegation zone on goal difference, so less clear what would have happened. "Possibly" yes. But who's to say that won't lose every remaining game of the season? It's extremely unlikely, but is still mathematically possible.
bmt Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 1 hour ago, st albans fox said: When I’m destitute on the streets next autumn, watching my team in the CL through the pub window will be all I have left to hang onto .... the love of your club is irrational.... I’m judging you to be too rational !!!! EDIT: I see your recent post ref current positions counting but I cannot see that being allowed by the majority in the league No I don’t think it will be either, but I think it’s the fairest option
Paninistickers Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 26 minutes ago, Vestan Pance said: Hard to believe no one thought there may be a situation one day where the season might not be completed. Really quite pathetic from this huge industry. It beggars belief really that it wasn't in the rules and that the PL lawyers probably copied and pasted a load of standard Ts and Cs Surely it wasn't radical thinking to pre suppose that a season in the future may possibly be curtailed due to war, natural disaster, strike, civil unrest, fuel/food shortages or other force majeure
st albans fox Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 12 minutes ago, Paninistickers said: It beggars belief really that it wasn't in the rules and that the PL lawyers probably copied and pasted a load of standard Ts and Cs Surely it wasn't radical thinking to pre suppose that a season in the future may possibly be curtailed due to war, natural disaster, strike, civil unrest, fuel/food shortages or other force majeure Quite incredible and I think a stain on scudamore’s legacy that he hadn’t covered it off .......
lcfc81 Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 5 hours ago, st albans fox said: I have read that children’s immune systems are much more sensitive as they are still developing and as such, they fight off the novel virus much more efficiently than us older folk whose bodies are tuned to expecting to see virus’ we’ve seen before and mutations of them so our systems have become ‘lazy’ at spotting a novel virus’. obviously it’s more technical than that explanation but you get the gist .... That makes some sense. It's all a bit baffling and a little worrying.
Mike the Metal Ed Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 2 hours ago, Paninistickers said: They HAVE to finish the season as somewhat unbelievably, it is not written into the rules what would happen in the event of a competition having to be cancelled. This means any decision other than completing the season is liable to legal challenge https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1939–40_Football_League There's prior prescendent, but as you say, Liverpool won't accept no title at this stage, and the bottom 3 won't accept relegation until mathematically certain. Could get interesting if a difficult decision has to be made at some point.
blueharmie Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 If the league can't continue it should be finished how it ended. And top two championship teams go up and when next season starts 5 go down. Best way and fair, but I don't think it will get to this
HybridFox Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 I'd be gutted if the rest of the FA Cup is scrapped. we're one game from a Wembley trip
CosbehFox Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 As it continues, I’m becoming increasingly sure that there will be no european competitions for a good period
Hollyfox Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 The only way that I would award the Premier League Title to Liverpool now, is if Tottenham were the only club that could mathematically catch them.
urban.spaceman Posted 15 March 2020 Author Posted 15 March 2020 25 minutes ago, st albans fox said: Italian league ideas apparently Option 3 sounds good for the PL. Imagine if we ended up winning the league by beating Liverpool in a play-off final despite being 29 points behind. That would, IMO, be justice for Mane's dive at Anfield, would create enough outrage from Merseyside it would be visible from SPACE, and would set me up for banter for the rest of my ****ing life. Do it.
lestajigs Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 10 minutes ago, urban.spaceman said: Option 3 sounds good for the PL. Imagine if we ended up winning the league by beating Liverpool in a play-off final despite being 29 points behind. That would, IMO, be justice for Mane's dive at Anfield, would create enough outrage from Merseyside it would be visible from SPACE, and would set me up for banter for the rest of my ****ing life. Do it. Did you go to the game at the kp mate? 😂😂
Jattdogg Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 To me, there can only be two options 1) null and void 2) finish the season. I vote finish the season when its possible to do so.
Tom12345 Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 I think the League should resume whenever it is feasible from a public health perspective and play the rest of the games. Shorten or cancel the next season instead. This seems to me to be fairest and least controversial - no one can then say Liverpool didnt really win it etc.
urban.spaceman Posted 15 March 2020 Author Posted 15 March 2020 31 minutes ago, lestajigs said: Did you go to the game at the kp mate? 😂😂 If anyone knows how to shithouse a win when we definitely don't deserve it, it's us.
whoareyaaa Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 21 minutes ago, Jattdogg said: To me, there can only be two options 1) null and void 2) finish the season. I vote finish the season when its possible to do so. I don't even think 1 is an option tbh we are 29 games in.
Jattdogg Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 Just now, whoareyaaa said: I don't even think 1 is an option tbh we are 29 games in. It really isnt but anything else is not true to the game. Someone will feel hard done in by a playoff and want to sue etc. You got to finish the season.
PaddyS Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 I think the players and the clubs will become bored within a few weeks and will ask the league/FA to allow them to finish the season by playing the remaining games behind closed doors.
FoyleFox Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 10 minutes ago, PaddyS said: I think the players and the clubs will become bored within a few weeks days and will ask the league/FA to allow them to finish the season by playing the remaining games behind closed doors. I am already.
PaddyS Posted 15 March 2020 Posted 15 March 2020 7 minutes ago, FoyleFox said: I am already. Imagine if the electricity was down as well. It doesn't bear thinking about!
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.