Ashley Posted 19 January 2019 Posted 19 January 2019 4 minutes ago, Tuna said: He won't leave Celtic in the middle of a title challenge. I take it you haven't read my original post then? Lol
Happy Fox Posted 19 January 2019 Posted 19 January 2019 10 minutes ago, Ashley said: I can't say who sir. Like I've said many a time before. Any info I get ill always share on here Bert and Abrasive confirmed it as well ? happy days!
Tuna Posted 19 January 2019 Posted 19 January 2019 1 minute ago, Ashley said: I take it you haven't read my original post then? Lol Nope but thanks My thoughts were Puel out in the summer and Brendan in.
The Bear Posted 19 January 2019 Posted 19 January 2019 Would you lot be happy with Sean Dyche? Only I heard a rumour the other day that he is the guy to back for the Leicester job if/when it comes available.
Ian Nacho Posted 19 January 2019 Posted 19 January 2019 Just now, The Bear said: Would you lot be happy with Sean Dyche? Only I heard a rumour the other day that he is the guy to back for the Leicester job if/when it comes available. Not exactly doing the business at Burnley.
ealingfox Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 I'd be incredibly disappointed with this. Bloke is a massive fraud and an utter twat to boot. We already have a manager who is doing a reasonable job. He is carrying out his remit - we've got our problems, just like we have had in 95+% of our seasons in existence. He deserves more time. This is just an unnecessary risk. I can't stand the way our players and our fans have become.
Jazzy_Jeff Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 4 minutes ago, ealingfox said: I'd be incredibly disappointed with this. Bloke is a massive fraud and an utter twat to boot. We already have a manager who is doing a reasonable job. He is carrying out his remit - we've got our problems, just like we have had in 95+% of our seasons in existence. He deserves more time. This is just an unnecessary risk. I can't stand the way our players and our fans have become. Whilst I agree that he is doing a reasonable job there have been decisions that he has made which has caused a lot of fans to lose faith continuing to pick morgan freezing out Silva and Iborra and only playing defensive minded centre mids chopping and changing of attacking players selling/loaning out two strikers without replacing them signing diabete and ghezzal negative tactics and team selection I could go on...
ROB-THE-BLUE Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 15 hours ago, Col city fan said: Maguire (If still here) becomes the obvious choice? Surely Kasper is the obvious choice?
FrankieADZ Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 16 hours ago, Ashley said: Now? Probably not. Summer? After what I've been told today it seems Puel is gone and BR is coming here. Believe it if you wish, or don't belive it. He wants to see this season out with Celtic. i believe that tbh, i cant imagine he'd come here during the middle of the season, and im guessing Rodgers would like to leave Celtic on a high so to speak in winning the league etc again and ending his spell there on a high
Collymore Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 23 minutes ago, ealingfox said: I'd be incredibly disappointed with this. Bloke is a massive fraud and an utter twat to boot. We already have a manager who is doing a reasonable job. He is carrying out his remit - we've got our problems, just like we have had in 95+% of our seasons in existence. He deserves more time. This is just an unnecessary risk. I can't stand the way our players and our fans have become Your post sums up what can make this forum insuffurable at times. One of the main problems with Foxestalk is finding balance. Yes, there are posters who are so anti-Puel it becomes difficult to read at times but for you to say he's doing a "reasonable job" and to imply you'd prefer Puel over Rodgers is just as ridiculous.
AlloverthefloorYesNdidi Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 Just now, Collymore said: Your post sums up what can make this forum insuffurable at times. One of the main problems with Foxestalk is finding balance. Yes, there are posters who are so anti-Puel it becomes difficult to read at times but for you to say he's doing a "reasonable job" and to imply you'd prefer Puel over Rodgers is just as ridiculous. Agree that balance is difficult, but i wouldnt say its unreasonable to say Puel is doing a reasonable job Really we are about where we woupd be expected to be atm The problem we will have if we sack him in the summer is that the pressure will be on because expectations will be to improve on what Puel has done Thats if we finish this seasom top half. If we do and then bring Rogers in anything less than 7th will be seen by many as a failure. Piles pressure on him and the club
ealingfox Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 23 minutes ago, Jazzy_Jeff said: Whilst I agree that he is doing a reasonable job there have been decisions that he has made which has caused a lot of fans to lose faith continuing to pick morgan freezing out Silva and Iborra and only playing defensive minded centre mids chopping and changing of attacking players selling/loaning out two strikers without replacing them signing diabete and ghezzal negative tactics and team selection I could go on... Morgan has not been any worse than our other defenders, he's been fine this season, as he was last season. It's clear he's going to be phased out from the end of this season. Maguire is having a poor season yet seems to get little to no criticism. Silva is shit and Iborra was clearly past it and was poor in the league games he did play. You can't blame recruitment solely on Puel. We have constraints that would have had an impact on trying to get a striker in. And wtf good would having Ulloa here do, he was an absolute donkey by the time he left! Diabate was a low risk, cheap signing that hasn't worked out so far - hardly crime of the century. Ghezzal is obviously a bit shit and that could have been foreseen but as has been explained many times he was an obvious panic buy because our recruitment team failed to get a top player in to replace Mahrez. That said as we've seen recently Ghezzals stats actually don't measure up that unfavourable against our other wide players. I notice you're criticising Puel for sticking with one player and critcising him for rotating others. Pretty much sums it up - if he kept changing the defenders because they weren't producing you'd then be criticising him for chopping and changing the defending players. It's ridiculous. Again there were no complaints playing 3 defensive-minded midfielders when we were beating Chelsea and Man City. Then there was uproar when he switched that for a more offensive formation at home. Then there was uproar when he switched back to that for the next home game. It's ridiculous. We're in the top half with a young first team and the squad being overhauled. Sometimes the tactics are negative but overall he is doing a reasonable job. He deserves more time.
l444ry Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 12 hours ago, The Bear said: Would you lot be happy with Sean Dyche? Only I heard a rumour the other day that he is the guy to back for the Leicester job if/when it comes available. Be a better fit than Rafa or Rodgers in my opinion.
ealingfox Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 8 minutes ago, Collymore said: Your post sums up what can make this forum insuffurable at times. One of the main problems with Foxestalk is finding balance. Yes, there are posters who are so anti-Puel it becomes difficult to read at times but for you to say he's doing a "reasonable job" and to imply you'd prefer Puel over Rodgers is just as ridiculous. He is doing a reasonable job and I would prefer Puel over Rodgers. You don't need to be an Puelite extremist to think that. If I was as you are suggesting surely I'd be saying he was doing a fantastic job?
Happy Fox Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 7 minutes ago, AlloverthefloorYesNdidi said: Agree that balance is difficult, but i wouldnt say its unreasonable to say Puel is doing a reasonable job Really we are about where we woupd be expected to be atm The problem we will have if we sack him in the summer is that the pressure will be on because expectations will be to improve on what Puel has done Thats if we finish this seasom top half. If we do and then bring Rogers in anything less than 7th will be seen by many as a failure. Piles pressure on him and the club I think Rodgers can cope with the pressure, he has managed in the premier league before.
AlloverthefloorYesNdidi Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 Just now, Happy Fox said: I think Rodgers can cope with the pressure, he has managed in the premier league before. Puel can cope with the pressure. Thats not really the issue If Rogers comes in and we dont get a solid 7th and we go out of the cups do you not think fans will see it as a failure and get on his back?
The Doctor Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 12 hours ago, The Bear said: Would you lot be happy with Sean Dyche? Only I heard a rumour the other day that he is the guy to back for the Leicester job if/when it comes available. I'd sooner shoot myself than have that gravel voiced budget Mourinho in charge
AjcW Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 Not entirely sure how anyone could call Rodgers a fraud... he was a slip away from taking THIS squad to a title... I mean yes they had Suarez and Coutinho but look at the rest of it!!
SouthStandUpperTier Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 Brendan Rodgers weirds me out a little. Guy looks like a Madame Tussaud's waxwork dummy.
Happy Fox Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 Just now, AlloverthefloorYesNdidi said: Puel can cope with the pressure. Thats not really the issue If Rogers comes in and we dont get a solid 7th and we go out of the cups do you not think fans will see it as a failure and get on his back? Are you sure? Didn't seem it yesterday.
sylofox Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 12 hours ago, The Bear said: Would you lot be happy with Sean Dyche? Only I heard a rumour the other day that he is the guy to back for the Leicester job if/when it comes available. Whatever it is your smoking can you pass it around the room. That would be like winning the lotto and binning off your battered old mini for a battered old mini.
ealingfox Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 12 minutes ago, AjcW said: Not entirely sure how anyone could call Rodgers a fraud... he was a slip away from taking THIS squad to a title... I mean yes they had Suarez and Coutinho but look at the rest of it!! Absolutely carried by the front four and powered by one of the best individual seasons the PL has ever seen in Suarez. The connection between a lot of the shit players there is that Rodgers signed them. And he's doing the same at Celtic. He even bought Balotelli ffs. They blew a 3-0 lead at Palace, it wasn't Gerrard's slip that cost them the title.
WigstonWanderer Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 2 minutes ago, ealingfox said: Absolutely carried by the front four and powered by one of the best individual seasons the PL has ever seen in Suarez. The connection between a lot of the shit players there is that Rodgers signed them. And he's doing the same at Celtic. He even bought Balotelli ffs. They blew a 3-0 lead at Palace, it wasn't Gerrard's slip that cost them the title. Stop, you’re putting me off!
MPH Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 14 minutes ago, AjcW said: Not entirely sure how anyone could call Rodgers a fraud... he was a slip away from taking THIS squad to a title... I mean yes they had Suarez and Coutinho but look at the rest of it!! Sterling.. Gerrard..
nwl fox Posted 20 January 2019 Posted 20 January 2019 1 hour ago, ealingfox said: I'd be incredibly disappointed with this. Bloke is a massive fraud and an utter twat to boot. We already have a manager who is doing a reasonable job. He is carrying out his remit - we've got our problems, just like we have had in 95+% of our seasons in existence. He deserves more time. This is just an unnecessary risk. I can't stand the way our players and our fans have become. Agree with all bar your opening sentence. Sadly there's no importance put on stability any more, so if there has to be change then I think BR would be a good fit. The most important thing for me is whoever is in charge continues to give priority to developing and bringing through our young talent
Recommended Posts
Archived
This topic is now archived and is closed to further replies.